Pros & Cons: 11 Countertop Materials Compared

Seattle kitchen quartz countertop

New countertops are expensive, so you expect them to last a long time. If you are remodeling your kitchen, your countertops will be the most costly material you pick out, surpassed only by your cabinetry package. You'll see them every day, prepare food on them, and need to keep them in good condition. Aesthetics and price are important considerations, but don't forget long-term durability and maintenance requirements when choosing the right materials. Read on to find out how the most popular materials compare.

Quartz

According to recent surveys, quartz countertops have finally surpassed natural granite in popularity. Also called manufactured stone, this material consists of ground up quartz (a natural mineral) that is bound together with resin and then molded into slabs. These days, more than 90% of our clients choose solid-surface quartz countertops because of the durability and easy maintenance. In recent years, the choice in colors and patterns has exploded. Quartz is available that mimics many natural stone slabs as well as many unique colors and patterns.

Pros

  • Resistant to heat, scratching, and stains
  • Many color and pattern choices available
  • Nonporous surface does not require sealing

Cons

  • Some quartz may slightly be less resistant to very high heat
  • May lack the unique patterns of natural stone

SEE ALSO: Quartz Vs. Granite: The Complete Guide [Euro Marble]

Kitchen with quartz countertop

Above: A Seattle kitchen with white quartz countertops. See more of this project.

Quartzite

This material is often confused for quartz, but unlike that engineered material, quartzite is a quarried natural stone.

Pros

  • Extremely hard, even more so than quartz
  • Variable pattern and coloring from the geologic forces that formed it

Cons

  • Depending on the quality of the slab, it can be pricey
  • Slightly more prone to denting and chipping than quartz
  • Designs that require complex cuts can be expensive

DSC_4328

Above: Pental Princess White Quartzite in a Mercer Island master bathroom.


Granite

Granite is now the second-most-popular countertop choice. It is available in a wide range of colors and natural patterns.

Pros

  • Each slab is unique
  • Extremely durable, resistant to scratching, heat, and stains (when properly sealed)

Cons

  • Prone to chipping
  • Must be resealed periodically
  • May emit small amounts of radon, a carcinogen

SEE ALSO: Natural and Manufactured Countertops: What's the Dif?

Granite Countertop

Above: Granite countertop by Pental Surfaces.


Soapstone

Soapstone lends a beautiful, warm look to a kitchen, with colors that range from almost solid white to charcoal gray, with lots of marbling.

Pros

  • Easy to clean non-porous surface
  • Resists acids
  • Scratches can be repaired with a bit of sandpaper and mineral oil

Cons

  • Scratches and mars easily, especially if the slab you choose has a higher talc content
  • Prone to chipping

Soapstone

Above: Natural soapstone slab.


Marble

This classic quarried stone has been a popular choice for kitchen countertops for ages. It traditional good looks add a touch of formality to a room.

Pros

  • Remains cool to the touch and is great for working with pastry
  • Honed marble can make scratches and stains less obvious
  • Prices vary widely but common Carrara marble can be one of the less expensive stone

Cons

  • Prone to etching from acidic foods
  • Scratches easily
  • Can be stained by fruits, wines, etc.

Marble slab

Above: Marble slab with pronounced veining.


Butcher Block

The timeless look of wood countertops is coming back in a big way. This warm, inviting material has its charm, but you also have to consider its drawbacks.

Pros

  • One of the least costly choices
  • Can be refinished to look like new
  • One of the few materials that can be installed by homeowners

Cons

  • Prone to scratching, denting, burning, and staining
  • Porous surface is sensitive to liquids
  • Must be sealed frequently

Butcher block

Above: Oiled butcher block countertops lend a warm feel to this vintage kitchen.


Concrete

You can achieve a wide variety of looks with concrete, from industrial to artistic.

Pros

  • Pigments and stains can achieve nearly any shade you desire
  • Resistant to heat and scratching

Cons

  • Must be resealed periodically
  • Can be stained by juice, oil, wine, and other liquids
  • Custom concrete work can be expensive

Laminate

Laminate has fallen out of favor from its boomerang-patterned heyday in the 1950s, but there are still reasons to consider this inexpensive option.

Pros

  • Among the least expensive options
  • Easy to install and can be changed frequently
  • A wide variety of colors and patterns are available

Cons

  • Can easily be burned, melted, and scratched
  • Probably not a good investment if you plan to sell your home

Paper Composite

This eco-friendly solid surface consists of many layers of recycled paper pressed together and bound with a resin. Paperstone and Richlite are two popular brands.

Pros

  • Has the look and feel of soft stone
  • Can be cut and shaped easily
  • Impervious to water and can be used indoors and outdoors
  • Surface scratches and scorch marks can be sanded out
  • Less expensive

Cons

  • Must be oiled yearly
  • Can be burned by hot pans
  • Will develop a patina over time

Corian

Corian and other brands of solid-surface countertops are made with polymer resins (plastic), sometimes mixed with sand. Although they have been somewhat eclipsed by quartz, solid-surface can still be a solid choice.

Pros

  • Available in many colors, including bright hues
  • Nonporous surface resists stains and is easy to clean
  • Seamless in appearance

Cons

  • Do not mimic natural materials as well as other manufactured countertop products
  • Prone to scratching, denting, and burning
  • Can't be polished to a glossy finish

Corian

Above: Corian countertop Deep Bedrock with Corian Farmsink Bold.


Porcelain

Only recently gaining in popularity, porcelain countertops such as Dekton and Neolith are a super-durable choice.

Pros

  • Even stronger than granite
  • Can be used outdoors because they don't contain resin
  • Heat and stain resistant
  • Recyclable

Cons

  • Blunt force, like a heavy pan falling from a high shelf, could crack them
  • Limited edge profile options

Dekton

Above: Modern kitchen with Dekton countertops.

Which countertop material is right for you?

Ultimately, your selection of a countertop material comes down to personal preference and priorities. The important thing is to look beyond the pretty surfaces and know the pros and cons of each material before making your decision. After all, you may be living with your countertops for many years, even decades. I hope this introduction will be a good jumping off point for your research and that you settle on a material that you will absolutely love. If you would like to start a discussion about a home remodel or if you just have questions, please contact us. We are always happy to try to be of service.

Article Categories: Interior Design, Design Tips And Trends, Kitchens

Guide to Hiring a Remodeler

This comprehensive guide walks you through all the steps of choosing who will design and build your project, vetting remodeling companies, and ensuring that you have the best experience.